Complex Shoulder and Elbow Second Opinions
A second opinion should do more than repeat the first diagnosis.
When is a second opinion useful?
A second opinion can be valuable when a patient has been advised to undergo shoulder or elbow surgery, is deciding between anatomic and reverse replacement, has persistent symptoms after rotator cuff repair, has pain after joint replacement, has recurrent instability after Bankart or Latarjet surgery, or is facing a complex fracture reconstruction. It is also appropriate when MRI or CT interpretations conflict, the proposed operation does not seem to match the patient's goals, or the patient wants a more detailed explanation of expected recovery and alternatives.
What the evaluation includes
Dr. Knudsen reviews the current symptoms, functional limitations, prior diagnoses, and treatment history. He personally reviews available X-rays, MRI, CT, ultrasound, operative reports, arthroscopic photographs, implant information, therapy records, injection history, and infection studies when relevant. A focused examination is used to determine whether the imaging findings match the patient's pain, weakness, stiffness, or instability. Additional testing is recommended only when it is likely to change the diagnosis or treatment plan.
What to bring
Patients should arrange secure transfer of the actual imaging studies, not only the written reports. Helpful records include operative reports, arthroscopic photographs, implant cards, therapy notes, laboratory or aspiration results, and a concise timeline of injuries, procedures, and recovery. A complete record can make a complex consultation more efficient, but missing records should not prevent the patient from beginning the evaluation.
Patient Experience
“I had been dealing with a shoulder injury for several years and had seen several specialists. Dr. Knudsen was very well informed about my case before I even walked in the door and performed the examination like an expert who understood every detail of the mechanics of my shoulder.”
Complex shoulder consultation patient | Google review
These testimonials describe individual patient experiences. Treatment recommendations, recovery, and outcomes vary by patient.
A clear recommendation, including uncertainty
Complex problems do not always have one perfect solution. A useful consultation explains what is known, what remains uncertain, what each procedure is intended to accomplish, and what it cannot reliably accomplish. The recommendation may be to proceed with the proposed operation, pursue a different surgical strategy, continue nonsurgical care, obtain more information, or avoid surgery because the expected benefit is insufficient. Dr. Knudsen's role is to provide clarity and a reasoned plan the patient can use, regardless of where treatment is ultimately performed.
Patient Experience
“I sustained very bad injuries in a bike accident, and Dr. Knudsen was so nuanced in his care. When others were saying I should get surgery, Dr. Knudsen was more wary of that approach. A year later, there is no question that Dr. Knudsen's approach was the right one.”
Trauma second-opinion patient | Google review
Time-sensitive problems
Recent fractures, fracture-dislocations, acute distal biceps or triceps ruptures, infected implants, open wounds, progressive neurologic weakness, and a cool or poorly perfused hand should not wait for a routine appointment. Patients with a recent injury should contact the office directly and identify the date and nature of the problem so the team can determine the appropriate level of urgency.
This information is educational and is not a substitute for an individualized medical evaluation. Written and medically reviewed by Michael L. Knudsen, MD | Last reviewed: July 2026
Request a Complex Second Opinion
Multiple locations across Westchester.
Contact NowOr call (212) 305-4565